In this blog’s introductory post, I mentioned that I was so moved by a dinner at Ken Oringer’s superlative Clio at the Eliot Hotel (Boston, MA) that I wanted to blog again. It had been years since I’ve written about food in an abortive attempt to establish a restaurant review blog for the Detroit Metropolitan Area. After that dinner at Clio, I felt I had to tell the world about Mr. Oringer’s outstanding restaurant and all the other great (and not-so-great) food I’ve experienced. Admittedly, it wasn’t just the food that moved me to blog again. It was the entire experience. It was the joy of sharing a wonderful meal with wonderful people. The proverbial “warm and fuzzy” feeling I had after this meal is really what influenced me to blog. During those three hours at Clio, I felt I was experiencing the best that life had to offer an epicurean soul.
If I really dig back to the roots of this blog, I have to go back even further to a friend’s bachelor party weekend, featuring dinners at Charlie Palmer Steak and Nobu in Las Vegas and to his wedding in May 2008. While I wasn’t floored by Charlie Palmer Steak, I was blown away by Nobu. I finally understood what my friend Eric meant by taking sushi to another level, a level beyond the standard ngiri and maki plates found everywhere else. At the wedding reception, I sat at a table with some of the same people who were at the dinner at Clio. The three of us who were at both the reception and the Clio dinner a month later sat with about eight other people. The eight other people at the table shared only a fraction of our zest for the ten-course Chinese feast before us. My friends and I had most of the food to ourselves. The eight less-adventurous souls chose to starve instead. Fine. More food for us. The following day, we met other friends for brunch at Blue Water Grill on Union Square in Manhattan and dinner at Matsuri in the basement of the Maritime Hotel. Sharing good food with good friends is what really drove me to write this blog.
With these experiences in mind, I had to share another great meal with great friends. My college buddy Eric and his wife Myha met my friend Kristine and me for dinner at Clio in June 2008. It was a humid summer evening in Boston. Kristine and I grabbed a cab and headed for Clio. We were a bit late. I called ahead to Eric to let him know. When Kristine and I finally arrived, we found Eric and Myha at the bar. We said our hellos and then took our seats.
I ordered a glass of champagne to start. Everyone else at the table agreed that the bubbly would be a good way to start. If I recall correctly, the ladies may have ordered cocktails, which they quickly abandoned in favor of the bubbly. So, a round of the bubbly, please! After quickly scanning the menu, Eric found that Clio offered a tasting menu. Immediately, I knew that’s what I wanted. Myha commented, “Leave it to Eric…to find the tasting menu.” Clio concocted both an eight-course tasting menu and a fourteen-course menu. Wine pairings were available for both. I knew I wanted wine. I knew I wanted food. I know I don’t know a lot about wine. So, this kind of arrangement is perfect for me. The first question became: Eight or fourteen courses? Eric looked to me for my input. I said, “Well, go big, or go home.” We all had a laugh at that. The next question to the group: wine pairing or no wine pairing. Eric looked to me again. I repeated my newfound mantra: “Go big, or go home.” We all laughed harder. I knew it was going to cost me, but I didn’t care. Some of my best friends with some of the best food I could find? How could I not “Go big?”
The menu is shown below for your reference. We all were very impressed by the dinner and the wine pairings. I knew that there was no way I could remember any of the details. I think Myha felt the same way. At the end of the meal, she asked the Sommelier, Christophe Richelet, if he could provide us with a list of the wines and the courses. He graciously e-mailed all the information to us. Thank you, Myha and Christophe. As I am writing this blog entry nearly four months after the dinner occurred, the details are fuzzy, but certain courses and wine pairings stand out like beautiful carved relief on the sandblasted ruins of my memory.
We started with the Sodas Inspired by Nature. Clio can, at times, adhere to the deconstructionist trend of molecular gastronomy. It was highly on display in this course. Small round-based volumetric flasks, similar to the triangular Erlenmeyer flasks you might remember from chemistry, were filled with these sodas. With the sodas came cones made from syrup and stuffed with popcorn and powdered cheese. We got the salty with the sweet. What was funny but a little off-putting was that there was no neat way to eat the popcorn cones. I got the white cheese powder everywhere. Thankfully, the table linens were white. Too bad my pants were black. As they say, “It’s all good.” The combination of the sweet, sugar cone and the salty popcorn and cheese was a fun, whimsical way to give me both the salty and the sweet.
Next, we received the Tomato Water Martini with Basil Oil, Caper Berry, and Tomato “Popsicle.” For this course, the only alcohol to be found was in the wine pairing, listed below. The tomato water was clear. The basil oil sat as green drops on the surface of the drink. The caper berry stood in place of a more traditional martini garnish, the olive. Served on the side was a diminutive cube of a frozen tomato concoction. The most impressive thing about this martini was that it actually tasted like a martini without the bite of the alcohol one might normally find in a cocktail. To this day, Kristine still reminisces with me about the martini.
Ken Oringer has a little sushi bar called Uni adjacent to Clio. The next two courses were from Uni. We had a tiradito of fluke with spicy pepper vinaigrette, yuzu, and hishio soy followed by iced Taylor Bay scallops with rhubarb verjus, Ossetra caviar, and fresh wasabi. The scallops were paired with the wonderful Riesling listed below. Unfortunately, the details of these two courses elude me, but trust me, they were fantastic. That much, I do remember. A cold soup of cucumber with yogurt, black onion powder, and olive oil was next. The next two courses were likewise excellent, but the details, again, are a little fuzzy four months later. The globe artichoke “anchoyade” with chanterelles, crispy salad, and frozen goat cheese powder was followed by surf clams with stinging nettle soup, chive flowers, and crispy potato.
Next, we received a crispy-skinned striped bass with lemon balm foam, green garlic, and young radish paired with a 2006 Merry Edwards Pinot Noir from the Russian River Valley. Though the details elude my memory, I do remember that this was a standout dish for all of us that night. Though one might question a pinot noir with fish, I assure you that the pairing was perfect. I think the flavor of the dish would have overpowered many whites, but the pinot was just light enough to be the right complement to the dish. Our sommelier Christophe did a marvelous job all night.
The next course again paired seafood with a red wine. The Clio staff served us a soft shell crab tempura with grilled ramps, wild lettuces and sauce diable. It reminded me of a similar dish I had at Nobu in Las Vegas. Our wine pairing was a 2002 Chateau La Rame Sainte-Croix-Du-Mont from Bordeaux. While excellent, I didn’t find the dish particularly groundbreaking for me. I preferred the soft shell crab tempura from Nobu.
Next up was the sweet Lacquered Foie Gras with strawberries, violet candy, and Oolong tea bitters. Christophe chose for us a 2004 Delas Hermitage “Marquise de la Tourette” from the Rhone River Valley. Apparently, the wine is made from the Syrah grape from a particularly notable region, which may help to explain why it was so perfectly paired with the foie gras as prepared above. The fruity, full-bodied Syrah went extremely well with the big flavors of the foie gras dish. For me, this course and the paired wine, were the best of the night. After that, we had veal and sweetbreads with the same wine. All I remember was that this too, was excellent. Probably, the most notable dishes that night were the sea bass and the foie gras. I remember that these two dishes seemed to impress us most.
What followed was essentially dessert. I have written elsewhere in this blog that a meal is akin to a sentence where the dessert functions as the period. To me, the real meaning is in the sentence. I think I’m just predisposed to pay less attention to dessert. I don’t know why, but that’s just the reality. I often say that I don’t have a sweet tooth; I have a fat and salt tooth. Perhaps, that’s why I don’t pay nearly as much attention to dessert as I do to the rest of the meal. I did love the sherry that we had with our wild strawberries with honey lemon crème and poppy ice cream. That much, I do remember.
Thank you to Eric, Myha, and Kristine for sharing that night at Clio with me. Thank you for being my complicit partners in crime. Thank you to Chef Ken Oringer, Sous Chef Andres Juilan Grundy, Pastry Chef Renae Herzog, and Sommelier Christophe Richelet. Though it was too long ago for me to remember all the details, I do remember it as one of the greatest meals of my life.
Chef’s Tasting Menu on Saturday June 21st, 2008.
Soda inspired by nature
Tomato Water Martini
with basil oil, caper berry and tomato “popsicle”
2006 Célestin Blondeau Sancerre “Cuvée des Moulins Bâles”, Loire
Tiradito of FLuke
with spicy pepper vinaigrette, yuzu and hishio soy
Iced Taylor Bay Scallops
with rhubarb verjus, ossetra caviar and fresh wasabi
2005 Domaine Otter Riesling Grand Cru “Schlossberg”, Alsace
Cold Soup of Cucumber
with yogurt, black onion powder and olive oil
Globe Artichoke “Anchoyade”
with chanterelles, crispy salad and frozen goat cheese powder
Surf Clams
with stinging nettle soup, chive flowers and crispy potato
2006 Naia Verdejo, Rueda
Crispy Skinned Striped Bass
with lemon balm foam, green garlic and young radish
2006 Merry Edwards Pinot Noir, Russian River Valley
Soft Shell Crab Tempura
with grilled ramps, wild lettuces and sauce Diable
2002 Château La Rame Sainte-Croix-Du-Mont, Bordeaux
Lacquered Foie Gras
with strawberries, violet candy and Oolong tea bitters
2004 Delas Hermitage “Marquise de la Tourette”, Rhône
Milk-Fed Veal “Scallopine” and Sweetbreads
with morel mushrooms fricassée, marjoram and aged sherry
La Tournette with Armagnac prunes
Fourme d’Ambert with spruce syrup and candied walnuts
Valencay with apricot and fig
Charolais with purple basil syrup and braised pear
Wild Strawberries
with honey lemon crème and poppy ice cream
Alvear ‘Sherry’ Pedro Ximénez Solera 1927, Montilla
Milk Chocolate ‘Bonbon’
with sarsaparilla ice cream, Bing cherries and cocoa nib